The Petition Just Hit 120,000 — And a Very Unconfirmed Rumor Has the Fandom Holding Its Breath

11 hours ago by Eli Gatewood 4 min read

---

The #SaveStargate petition crossed 120,000 signatures this week, with organizers taking the campaign straight into DragonCon's crowds in Atlanta. And now there's a rumor floating around — thin, unconfirmed, and worth exactly the grain of salt it comes with — that Amazon might not be as done with this as it's pretending to be.

Let's start with the number, because it's the one thing in this update that's actually verified: the Change.org petition to reverse Amazon MGM's cancellation of Martin Gero's Stargate revival crossed 120,000 signatures this week. Three months ago that number was in the tens of thousands. It has not stopped climbing, and Amazon has not said one public word about it.

Organizers didn't let it sit there as a screenshot, either. The campaign set up shop at DragonCon in Atlanta over Labor Day weekend, working the floor in front of tens of thousands of attendees who weren't necessarily there for Stargate specifically but absolutely know what a Stargate is. Campaign organizer James Kerfoot put the pitch about as plainly as it gets: "There are millions of Stargate fans across the world; the shows are consistently trending on Amazon Prime, despite no new episodes airing for fifteen years." That's the whole #SaveStargate argument in one sentence — the audience never left, the platform's own numbers supposedly prove it, and the "not broad enough appeal" rationale Amazon gave back in June doesn't hold up against a franchise still finding new fans a decade and a half after Stargate Universe went off the air.

Franchise veterans are still lending their names to it too — Michael Shanks, Rachel Luttrell, David Hewlett, and Robert Patrick have all put public support behind the campaign at this point. That's four actors spanning SG-1 and Atlantis both, which tells you this isn't a nostalgia campaign for one corner of the franchise. It's the whole gate team showing up.

Now, About That Rumor

Here's where I have to put my hardcore-gate-nerd hat down and put my "I don't fabricate news" hat on, because there's a rumor going around and it deserves exactly the skepticism it's asking for.

A podcast called Tachyon Pulse reported this week that Amazon might be reconsidering the June cancellation. The source: an unnamed contact at a major California talent agency, who claims a client attached to the cancelled project turned down another job, citing an ongoing commitment to Stargate despite the public cancellation. The implication is that Amazon is quietly keeping talent on retainer while internal conversations about reviving the project continue behind closed doors.

I want to be straight with you about how thin that is. It's one anonymous secondhand account, relayed by a podcast host who described his own confidence level like this: "I'm so far into the country of rumor that I can't see the border." That's about as honest a disclaimer as you'll get from anyone reporting on this stuff, and I respect it — but it also means there's nothing here beyond one person's account of one talent decision. No quote from Amazon. No quote from Martin Gero. No quote from anyone actually inside the greenlight room. The one thing lending it any weight at all is that the same source apparently called the original Gero series announcement accurately before it happened, back before Christmas 2025.

So: is Stargate quietly being un-cancelled? I genuinely don't know, and neither does anyone reporting this. What I do know is that a fandom sitting at 120,000 signatures, four legacy cast members publicly attached, a DragonCon activation, an SG-1 rewatch podcast landing in October, and now a rumor with just enough specificity to be tantalizing — that's not a campaign running out of steam. If anything, it's a campaign that's earned the right to make Amazon's silence look worse every week it continues.

Grounded Optimism, As Usual

I've been telling you for months now that none of the billboards or banners or podcast launches are going to single-handedly force Amazon's hand — and that's still true today. Petitions don't renew shows; executives do, for reasons that are usually more about quarterly programming slates than fan sentiment. But 120,000 people didn't sign a form and move on. They're showing up at conventions, they're getting cast members to co-sign, and now they've got a rumor circulating that's specific enough to keep the conversation alive without anyone having to pretend it's confirmed.

I'll take that over silence. Chevron's still not locked. But for the first time in a while, there's actual chatter about whether it might be — even if that chatter comes with every asterisk in the book attached to it.